Liquid Stake with compassSOL for an 7.15% APY from staking, MEV + fees

Enjoy the freedom of liquid staking in Solana Defi while delegating your stake to the high performance Solana Compass validator. Stake or unstake at any time here, or with a Jupiter swap.

Benefit from our high staking returns and over 2 years experience operating a Solana validator, and receive additional yield from priority fees + MEV tips

Earn 6.5% APY staking with Solana Compass

Help decentralize and secure the Solana network delegating your stake to us and earn an impressive 6.5% APY yield on your SOL, while supporting us to create new guides and tools. Learn more

Stake your SOL

  1. Click to connect your wallet
  2. Enter the amount you wish to stake
  3. Kick back and enjoy your returns
  4. Unstake from your wallet or our staking dashboard

Earn 6.5% APY staking with Solana Compass

Help decentralize and secure the Solana network delegating your stake to us and earn an impressive 6.5% APY yield on your SOL, while supporting us to create new guides and tools.

Learn more

Debate: SVMs on Ethereum Are Competitive to Solana Mainnet

By breakpoint-24

Published on 2024-09-21

A debate on whether SVM implementations on Ethereum compete with or complement Solana's mainnet

The notes below are AI generated and may not be 100% accurate. Watch the video to be sure!

The battle for blockchain supremacy heats up as experts debate whether Solana Virtual Machine (SVM) implementations on Ethereum pose a competitive threat to Solana's mainnet or offer new opportunities for cross-chain collaboration and growth.

Summary

At Breakpoint 2024, industry experts engaged in a thought-provoking debate on the relationship between Solana Virtual Machine (SVM) implementations on Ethereum and Solana's mainnet. The discussion centered around whether these Ethereum-based SVMs are competitive or complementary to Solana's ecosystem.

Terry Chung from Eclipse, which is building an SVM Layer 2 solution that settles on Ethereum, argued that their approach is not parasitic to Solana. He emphasized that Eclipse uses Celestia for data availability and is connected to Solana via a third-party bridge, making it fundamentally different from direct competition with Solana's mainnet.

Kevin Galler from Monad Labs presented a counterargument, suggesting that any system capturing fees and MEV (Miner Extractable Value) that could potentially go to Solana's mainnet validators is inherently competitive. The debate touched on issues of state fragmentation, developer mindshare, and the trade-offs between integrated and modular blockchain architectures.

Both parties acknowledged potential benefits of cross-chain development, such as improved tooling and increased developer interest in the Solana ecosystem. However, they differed on the long-term implications for Solana's vision of a unified global state machine.

Key Points:

Competitive vs. Complementary Ecosystems

Terry Chung argued that Eclipse's SVM implementation on Ethereum is not directly competitive with Solana's mainnet. He emphasized that the state on Eclipse is non-fungible and non-substitute, meaning that many actions possible on Solana mainnet cannot be replicated on Eclipse due to differences in available assets and use cases. This distinction, in his view, makes Eclipse more of a complementary system that can potentially introduce Ethereum developers to the Solana ecosystem.

Kevin Galler, on the other hand, maintained that any system that captures fees and MEV that could otherwise go to Solana mainnet is inherently competitive. He argued that if Solana's goal is to be a global, unified state machine, then any fragmentation of state across different systems works against this vision. Galler also pointed out that competition for developer mindshare and time is a factor, as building for multiple environments can be challenging and time-consuming.

State Fragmentation and Blockchain Architecture

The debate touched on the philosophical differences between integrated and modular blockchain architectures. Solana's original vision of replacing traditional financial systems with a single, high-performance blockchain was contrasted with the modular approach of using layer 2 solutions and separate data availability layers.

Terry argued that modularity allows for specialization and potentially faster innovation in specific areas like data availability. He cited Celestia's progress in achieving high throughput for data availability as an example of the benefits of a modular approach.

Kevin countered that integrated chains offer better composability and lower latency, which are crucial for certain financial applications. He expressed concerns about the additional complexity and trust assumptions introduced by modular systems, especially for developers and users who need to reason about different layers.

Developer Adoption and Ecosystem Growth

Both parties acknowledged potential benefits of cross-chain development for the broader ecosystem. Terry highlighted that Eclipse could serve as an entry point for Ethereum developers curious about Solana, potentially leading to increased adoption of Solana's mainnet in the future. He also mentioned exciting use cases like Solana-based DeFi using Ethereum assets as collateral.

Kevin agreed that developer tooling improvements and reduced vendor lock-in could be positive outcomes. However, he cautioned against the mentality of simply deploying the same applications across multiple chains without finding true product-market fit, emphasizing the need for innovation and new use cases tailored to each ecosystem's strengths.

Facts + Figures

  • Breakpoint 2024 saw 6,000 tickets sold, making it the most packed event in its four-year history
  • Eclipse is building the first SVM Layer 2 that settles on Ethereum and uses Celestia for data availability
  • Monad Labs is developing an EVM-compatible blockchain with a focus on high performance
  • Celestia is targeting 1 gigabyte blocks on their mainnet, potentially outpacing integrated chains in data availability throughput
  • The debate touched on the trade-offs between having a single centralized sequencer versus a full permissionless validator set
  • The proliferation of blockchain scaling solutions has led to discussions about state fragmentation across different layers and chains
  • Real-time censorship resistance was highlighted as a crucial factor for certain financial applications, especially in market making and order book management

Top quotes

  1. "Eclipse is kind of like a beachhead that is like a Solana infiltration into the Ethereum ecosystem." - Terry Chung
  2. "If you want to be the world's global synchronized state machine, I do think all L1s and L2s have an element of competitiveness." - Kevin Galler
  3. "The fact that there is a wormhole bridge connecting Avalanche and Solana does not make Avalanche DeFi directly competitive and parasitic against the MEV and the fees of Solana Mainnet." - Terry Chung
  4. "I think if you're an app and your expansion plan is just to go to another chain because you didn't find product market fit on the original chain, I don't know how that's supposed to solve the problem." - Kevin Galler
  5. "By specializing, you have people who are just working and focusing on one thing. And that improves that exponential pace faster than people focusing on that whole integrated environment." - Terry Chung

Questions Answered

What is the main debate about SVMs on Ethereum versus Solana mainnet?

The debate centers on whether Solana Virtual Machine (SVM) implementations that settle on Ethereum are competitive or complementary to Solana's mainnet. Proponents argue that these implementations can serve as an entry point for Ethereum developers into the Solana ecosystem, while critics contend that they fragment the state and potentially divert fees and MEV away from Solana's validators.

How does Eclipse's SVM Layer 2 solution differ from Solana mainnet?

Eclipse's SVM Layer 2 settles on Ethereum and uses Celestia for data availability, rather than settling directly on Solana. It connects to Solana via a third-party bridge, which means it doesn't directly compete for fees and MEV with Solana's mainnet. The state and available assets on Eclipse are also different from Solana mainnet, enabling distinct use cases.

What are the potential benefits of SVM implementations on Ethereum for Solana?

SVM implementations on Ethereum could introduce more developers to the Solana ecosystem, improve cross-chain tooling, and potentially lead to increased adoption of Solana's mainnet. They may also enable new use cases, such as Solana-based DeFi using Ethereum assets as collateral, which could expand the overall ecosystem.

What concerns are raised about Layer 2 solutions and state fragmentation?

Critics argue that Layer 2 solutions and cross-chain implementations can fragment the blockchain state, potentially working against Solana's vision of a unified global state machine. There are also concerns about increased complexity, additional trust assumptions, and potential latency issues when dealing with separate execution and data availability layers.

How do integrated chains compare to modular blockchain architectures?

Integrated chains like Solana offer better composability and lower latency, which can be crucial for certain financial applications. Modular architectures, on the other hand, allow for specialization and potentially faster innovation in specific areas like data availability. The debate highlights the trade-offs between these approaches in terms of performance, scalability, and ecosystem development.


Related Content

Building Sig, a New Read-Optimized Solana Validator

A look into SIG, the new read-optimized Solana validator aiming to improve blockchain performance and decentralization.

Researching the Solana Ecosystem: Challenges, Learnings, and Opportunities

An exploration of the current state and future possibilities within the Solana Ecosystem

Breakpoint 2023: tBTC comes to Solana

Discussions on the integration of tBTC, a decentralized Bitcoin, into the Solana ecosystem.

Solana vs Ethereum Fee Markets | Mert Mumtaz, Dan Smith

Explore how Solana's fee revenue is approaching Ethereum's, the impact of failed transactions, and the evolving L2 landscape post-EIP-4844.

Solana vs Ethereum: Two Paths, One Endgame | Jon Charbonneau

Explore the convergence of Solana and Ethereum scaling strategies, the future of rollups, and the importance of social layers in blockchain ecosystems.

Breakpoint 2023: How to Build Neon on Solana

Neon Labs co-founder unveils advancements in Neon EVM, promising high transaction throughput and interoperability for Ethereum apps on Solana.

Breakpoint 2023: Account Abstraction on Solana

Squads Labs presents the innovative account abstraction protocol on Solana, revolutionizing security and usability for developers and users.

Has Solana Earned The Hype? | Mert Mumtaz, Garrett Harper

Explore Solana's recent surge, its technological advantages over Ethereum, and the potential for breakthrough applications in this in-depth analysis from Lightspeed podcast.

Ethereum Merge Explained in 10 Minutes | Superteam Clips

Understand the Ethereum Merge, its impact, and what to expect post-merge in this comprehensive breakdown of the transition from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake.

Will Solana Surpass Ethereum In Economic Value? | Mert Mumtaz

Explore the potential of Solana surpassing Ethereum in economic value, validator profitability, and the rise of social DApps in this in-depth analysis.

The Ethereum Merge Explained | Superteam Clips

Discover the implications of Ethereum's shift to Proof-of-Stake, its impact on users, and why it's a milestone in human coordination. Learn why Solana remains the superior blockchain.

Breakpoint 2023: DRiP on Solana

A discussion on the evolution and success of DRiP, a Web3 platform on Solana, and its impact on crypto engagement and creator monetization.

Breakpoint 2023: How to Store Solana NFTs On-Chain - A Brief Overview

An insightful exploration into the essentials of storing NFTs on Solana's blockchain.

Breakpoint 2023: Phantom Quests

Phantom introduces an engaging incentive program to explore new features and understand the Solana ecosystem with Phantom Quests.

Breakpoint 2023: The Evolution of The Solana Community

An insightful discussion on the growth and future of Solana's NFT community featuring industry experts.